What Should I Do About Billing Problems When Using HSA Money?


If you run into a billing problem or misunderstanding with a hospital or doctor's office for which you're planning to use money from your Health Savings Account (HSA), you could be in trouble.

This article will help you understand how hospital and doctor visits are different when paying with a Health Savings Account. Not better or worse, just different.

If you have an HSA, you must have health insurance. It's a requirement. However, if you are using money from your HSA, it means that you haven't hit the deductible of your policy yet.

In this particular situation, life is a bit different when it comes to resolving billing disputes with hospitals.

Insurance companies have a comprehensive system for dealing with billing disputes when they have covered a hospital stay or doctor visit. But when they haven't covered it because you are still within your deductible, that comprehensive dispute resolution system doesn't necessarily apply.

Here are some points to keep in mind when you are dealing with a hospital in a billing dispute, and you have paid with HSA money. I learned these important points when I was talking to an expert in this field named Dr. Vincent Riccardi, who is the owner of American Medical Consumer (www.medconsumer.com), a company dedicated to helping people resolve billing disputes with hospitals and doctors.

Here's what Dr. Riccardi has to say:

  • First, discuss the issue with your physician. Sometimes the problem stems from an incorrectly applied billing code and the doctor can easily change it to please the hospital and resolve the problem on the spot.
  • Negotiate in person. Especially if you just don't have the money to pay a bill, it makes the best sense to negotiate face-to-face with the person at the hospital who has the authority to reverse or reduce the charges. Hospitals would often rather be paid part of a bill than risk losing the entire bill. Be honest and forthright and you may have a good chance in negotiating a reduced fee from the hospital. This includes the situations where it was a misunderstanding on your part. It's at least worth a try.
  • Don't bother going to the State Medical Board. In most cases, they are not able to help you. This is the case with most government agencies. Even the Departments of Insurance cannot help, because this isn't an insurance problem, it is technically a fee-for-service situation.
  • Recourse to a lawyer is usually not fruitful unless there is a big amount involved. For amounts less than $5,000 (which is what most HSA-style deductibles are), a lawyer probably won't be able to help you.
  • Remember that the only things that count in negotiations like this are the things that have been written down. If a doctor mentioned something to you but didn't write it down, it probably won't help you. Get things in writing all the way through the process.
  • I think of HSAs as a way to "be your own insurance company" for the small stuff (under your deductible). That is its power. But it also means that when it comes to disputes, you also have to "be your own insurance company" and take charge of the negotiations with the hospital, just like an insurance company would. Your willingness and ability to negotiate will influence your ability to get unfair charges reversed or, at least, lessened. But it's a "do it yourself" situation, so be aware of that when you sign up for an HSA.

    Daryl Kulak is the author of the book "Health Insurance Off the Grid - A Wonderful Way to Use Alternative Medicine and Save Money on Insurance Using the New Health Savings Account (HSA)."

    The book provides a nine-step plan to get your self-employed or small business health insurance costs under control using a unique approach you won't find anywhere else. The book is available for sale as an e-Book or paperback at the Website http://www.healthoffthegrid.com





    Latest News:



    Site: Yahoo! News Search Results for news
    Futures flat; Lehman buyout news, data awaited (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
    Stock index futures were little changed on Friday as investors awaited news on the fate of Lehman Brothers after a slide in its stock this week heightened fears over whether the investment bank can survive. Myanmar's Suu Kyi to get family letters, news mags (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
    Detained Myanmar opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi has managed to wring small concessions from the ruling generals in the form of letters from her family and some international news magazines, her lawyer said on Friday. SEC Looks Into UAL Stock Scare; Implications For Online News? (CBS News)
    A ton of digits have been devoted to this in other spots but the SEC's decision to investigate takes it to another level. The backstory: a six-year-old news story about UAL declaring bankruptcy made it into the Tribune-owned Sun-Sentinel 's current news flow, was picked up by a Google (NSDQ: GOOG) News bot and, via a reporter for a newsletter, made it onto Bloomberg News. After a lot of buck ... JCDecaux in talks for News Outdoor Group in Russia (AP via Yahoo! News)
    French outdoor advertising firm JCDecaux SA said Thursday it is negotiating to buy Russian rival News Outdoor Group from global media company News Corp. News Corp tightens grip on Premiere with new CEO (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
    Rupert Murdoch tightened his grip on German pay-TV broadcaster Premiere by appointing News Corp executive Mark Williams as CEO in a move to get the company back on track. Phila. mayor to announce grim budget news (The Philadelphia Inquirer)
    The Nutter administration is expected to announce grim budget news today, which is all but certain to lead to significant spending cuts - perhaps as high as 10 percent - in some city departments, according to three sources familiar with the budget. Help News pick Stadium's greatest moment (New York Daily News)
    The News is marking the countdown to the final game at The House That Ruth Built by reflecting on Yankee Stadium's greatest moments - and we're asking you - the reader - to help us pick out the best of the best. JCDecaux and News Corp. in talks to combine outdoor ad groups (International Herald Tribune)
    The News Corp. chief executive, Rupert Murdoch, has recently expressed nervousness about investments in Russia, where News Outdoor generated the bulk of its revenue last year. SEC Looks Into UAL Stock Scare; Implications For Online News? (paidContent.org via Yahoo! Finance)
    A ton of digits have been devoted to this in other spots but the SEC's decision to investigate takes it to another level. The backstory: a six-year-old news story about UAL declaring bankruptcy made it into the Tribune-owned Sun-Sentinel's current news flow, was picked up by a Google News bot and, via a reporter for a newsletter, made it onto Bloomberg News. JCDecaux in talks to buy News Corp. billboard unit (AP via Yahoo! Finance)
    In a deal that would create the world's largest outdoor advertising company, French conglomerate JCDecaux SA said Thursday that it is in talks to buy Russian rival News Outdoor Group from global media company News Corp.

    Site: news - Google News
    News Analysis A Difficult Road Awaits Panetta at the CIA - New York Times

    News Analysis A Difficult Road Awaits Panetta at the CIA
    New York Times, United States - 5 hours ago
    The latest on the presidential transition and other political news from Washington and around the nation. Join the discussion. For Leon E. Panetta, ...
    Video: Analyst Weighs in on Obama's CIA Pick AssociatedPress
    News roundup: Israel presses on in Gaza; Obama tries to reassure GOP USA Today
    Hotspots: Breaking news from around the world Chicago Sun-Times
    Huffington Post - The Associated Press
    all 2,587 news articles
    Warsh?s Crisis Skills Propel Him Toward New York Fed Candidacy - Bloomberg

    Warsh?s Crisis Skills Propel Him Toward New York Fed Candidacy
    Bloomberg - 2 hours ago
    9 (Bloomberg) -- The Federal Reserve is nearing a decision on the next president of the New York Fed, with Kevin Warsh?s Wall Street background and role in ...
    CNET News Daily Podcast: Say hello to the Palm Pre - CNET News

    San Francisco Chronicle

    CNET News Daily Podcast: Say hello to the Palm Pre
    CNET News, CA - 11 hours ago
    At the CES gadget extravaganza in Las Vegas, Palm has just unveiled its much-anticipated new handset, the Palm Pre, which features the new Palm Web OS. ...
    Palm's new Pre smartphone gets lots of good buzz USA Today
    Palm unveils new smart phone, operating system The Associated Press
    Palm strikes back with new OS, pré handset at CES Ars Technica
    San Francisco Chronicle - TG Daily
    all 442 news articles
    Amid Sales Slump, Chico's Taps New CEO - Wall Street Journal

    Amid Sales Slump, Chico's Taps New CEO
    Wall Street Journal - 3 hours ago
    The announcement came as Spotlight Capital Management LLC, a New York hedge fund that has been pressing the board to name a new CEO since last March, ...
    Chico's says same-store sales off 12.4%, taps new CEO MarketWatch
    Struggling Chico's taps new chief The News-Press
    all 30 news articles
    Yahoo reportedly near decision on new CEO - CNET News

    CNET News

    Yahoo reportedly near decision on new CEO
    CNET News, CA - 1 hour ago
    Yahoo is said to be wrapping up its search for a new chief executive, and a decision could come as early as next week, according to a report late Thursday ...
    China calls for full, effective implementation of new UN ... - Xinhua

    Washington Post

    China calls for full, effective implementation of new UN ...
    Xinhua, China - 1 hour ago
    8 (Xinhua) -- China on Thursday called for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza, and the comprehensive and effective implementation of the new Security Council ...
    New UN Gaza resolution proposed Aljazeera.net
    AP Top News at 11:27 pm EST The Associated Press
    News roundup: Lebanese rocket northern Israel; passengers ... USA Today
    Times Online - Boston Herald
    all 11,085 news articles
    Summary Of Thursday News From International Consumer Electronics Show - CNNMoney.com

    ABC News

    Summary Of Thursday News From International Consumer Electronics Show
    CNNMoney.com - 11 hours ago
    The company's Sling Media Inc. unit unveiled SlingGuide, a new Web-based way to find, watch and record your favorite television programming from anywhere. ...
    Video: Loaded: Happy New Year! CBS
    New TV trends unveiled at gadget show abc7.com
    CES 2009: All the news IT PRO
    CBS News - ComputerWeekly.com
    all 1,266 news articles
    Ballmer touts Windows 7 beta, new deals - CNET News

    New York Times

    Ballmer touts Windows 7 beta, new deals
    CNET News, CA - 21 hours ago
    Microsoft will also announce new deals for Windows Live that will see Microsoft's search engine become the default on PCs from Dell as well as touting a ...
    Microsoft's news at CES not so new Seattle Times
    CES News: Ballmer Keynote Doesn?t Quite Fit The Bill Twice
    Windows Live Essentials released, more Windows Live news from CES LiveSide
    CRN - UK - MarketWatch
    all 1,181 news articles
    Vizio's Wireless TV Connects to the Web Through New 'Widget Stream' - Wired News

    Chippewa Herald

    Vizio's Wireless TV Connects to the Web Through New 'Widget Stream'
    Wired News - 8 hours ago
    Vizio is surprisingly one of the biggest players, with a new 'Connected HDTV' platform announced this week that packs in 802.11n Wi-Fi and streams in media ...
    New TV trends: Internet movies, 3-D, power saving The Associated Press
    CES News: Samsung Intros LED TV With Internet Content Twice
    CES: Samsung+Yahoo=wow, plus new Blu-ray, thin TVs and SSD camcorder Seattle Times
    Compound Semiconductors Online (press release) - Which?
    all 421 news articles
    Thrift stores exempted from new lead-testing law - Houston Chronicle

    USA Today

    Thrift stores exempted from new lead-testing law
    Houston Chronicle, United States - 1 hour ago
    A new ruling means thrift stores are not required to have toys tested for lead and chemicals. According to the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act, ...
    New rules on toys could spell doom USA Today
    Consignment owners say new law puts burden on them Frederick News Post (subscription)
    More news on the Consumer Product Safety Improvement Act Los Angeles Times
    LocalNews8.com - KARE
    all 131 news articles

    MORE RESOURCES:
    Site: Yahoo! News Search Results for insurance
    NC insurance commissioner orders lower auto rates (AP via Yahoo! Finance)

    North Carolina State Insurance Commissioner Jim Long on Thursday rejected an industry request for an almost 13 percent increase in auto rates and has ordered a reduction instead. Auto-insurance rates in N.C. ordered cut by 16.1 percent (Winston-Salem Journal)

    N.C. Insurance Commissioner Jim Long rejected yesterday an industry request for an almost 13 percent increase in auto rates and has ordered a reduction instead. Survey: Insurance Industry Expects Subprime Issues to Negatively Impact 2009 Performance (Insurance Journal)

    Insurance executives expect subprime and other credit issues to continue to have a significantly negative impact on the industry's financial performance in 2009, and they see credit and pricing risks Nevada Names Baker Acting Insurance Commissioner (Insurance Journal)

    The Nevada Department of Business & Industry named Betty C. Baker acting commissioner of the Division of Insurance. Baker will oversee the Division while a replacement is sought for Alice Molasky-Arma Here's the lowdown on 'private' bank and broker insurance (USA Today)

    Q: I've noticed several banks and brokerage firms claiming they have private insurance that protects accounts above the FDIC and SIPC limits. Should investors trust those promises? State unemployment insurance claims up (Macon Telegraph)

    The Georgia Department of Labor announced Thursday that 59,090 laid-off workers filed first-time claims for unemployment insurance benefits in August, an increase of 72.1 percent from August 2007, but a slight decrease from July to August this year. Fitch Ratings Gives Island Insurance an "Aq" (Insurance Journal)

    Island Insurance Co. Ltd., Hawaii's largest locally owned and managed property and casualty insurance carrier, has reaffirmed its "Aq" rating for Quantitative Insurer Financial Strength (Q-IFS) by Fit Looking for Free or Low-cost Health Insurance? (Carteret County News-Times)

    (ARA) - It's no secret that accessing health care is a challenge for the 47 million Americans who are uninsured. Lack of health insurance forces many Americans to choose the health care they receive based on what they can afford, not what they actually need. Uganda: Health Insurance May Face NSSF Fate (AllAfrica.com)

    The government has finally resolved that all salaried workers and employers, will with effect from July 2009, be required to make compulsory contributions to the new National Social Health Insurance Scheme. The net inflow from life insurance companies into equity stood at Rs550bn till March 31, 2008 , foreign institutional ... (India Infoline)

    The life insurance industry was the largest investor in the Indian equity markets, ahead of foreign institutional investors and mutual funds, according to the reports. Site: insurance - Google News
    Obama Plan for Government Insurance Draws Criticism - Bloomberg

    New York Times

    Obama Plan for Government Insurance Draws Criticism
    Bloomberg - 12 hours ago
    8 (Bloomberg) -- President-elect Barack Obama?s plan for expanding government health insurance to compete with private coverage drew fire from a leading ...
    Video: Ted Kennedy Speaks To CBS News CBS
    US health care overhaul needn't break bank: study Reuters
    Cuddly Welcome for Mr. Daschle New York Times
    EurekAlert (press release) - SmartBrief
    all 665 news articles
    Insurance brokers EPIC and Arthur J. Gallagher settle lawsuit - Bizjournals.com

    Insurance brokers EPIC and Arthur J. Gallagher settle lawsuit
    Bizjournals.com, NC - 9 hours ago
    Edgewood Partners Insurance Center, a San Mateo-based insurance brokerage and employee benefits consulting firm also known as EPIC, said late Thursday it ...
    EPIC Announces Settlement with Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. Insurance Journal
    Edgewood Partners Announces Settlement with Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. MarketWatch (press release)
    Arthur J. Gallagher & Co. Announces Settlement With Edgewood Partners PR Newswire (press release)
    all 19 news articles
    Insurance agent pleads guilty in mortgage fraud case - Bizjournals.com

    Insurance agent pleads guilty in mortgage fraud case
    Bizjournals.com, NC - 11 hours ago
    A self-employed insurance agent admitted guilt for his role in a $12.6 million mortgage fraud scheme that encompassed 25 residential properties in Lee?s ...
    Gladstone man admits role in Southland mortgage fraud case Kansas City Star
    Man pleads guilty in $12.6 million mortgage fraud scam Kansas City Star
    all 12 news articles
    What you should know about flood insurance - Seattle Post Intelligencer

    What you should know about flood insurance
    Seattle Post Intelligencer - 2 hours ago
    By DAN RICHMAN Here's some basic information about flood insurance provided by Mike Howard, a spokesman for the Bothell office of the Federal Emergency ...
    Flood facts and coverage KGET 17
    all 2 news articles
    Louisiana Citizens Property Insurance Corp. approves rate increase - The Times-Picayune - NOLA.com

    WWL

    Louisiana Citizens Property Insurance Corp. approves rate increase
    The Times-Picayune - NOLA.com, LA - 1 hour ago
    By Rebecca Mowbray BATON ROUGE -- Louisiana Citizens Property Insurance Corp. adopted a statewide average rate increase of 7 percent in a 5-1 vote Thursday, ...
    Citizens insurance rates to rise 7 percent 2TheAdvocate
    Task force lays out plans to reform Fla. Citizens Property Insurance SmartBrief
    Task force: Hike rates for Citizens Bizjournals.com
    Sarasota Herald-Tribune - KATC
    all 58 news articles
    California Hosts Insurance Recovery Forum for Wildfire Survivors - Insurance Journal

    California Hosts Insurance Recovery Forum for Wildfire Survivors
    Insurance Journal, CA - 1 hour ago
    California Insurance Commissioner Steve Poizner is hosting town hall-style Insurance Recovery Forums for survivors of the November 2008 wildfires. ...
    State: Man Staged Theft, Torcing Of Truck KCRA.com
    Poizner announces sentencing of Sacramento woman SmartBrief
    all 9 news articles
    Can Madoff payouts break the insurance bank? - San Francisco Chronicle

    New York Daily News

    Can Madoff payouts break the insurance bank?
    San Francisco Chronicle,  USA - Jan 7, 2009
    But if clients of Bernie Madoff wipe out the insurance fund, will there be any protection for everyone else? In interviews and congressional testimony this ...
    National business: Madoff hid $173 million from authorities; SEC ... Kansas City Star
    clients fear getting shut out of refunds Reuters
    all 271 news articles
    Troubled insurers put under control of Pa. agency - Forbes

    Troubled insurers put under control of Pa. agency
    Forbes, NY - 8 hours ago
    AP , 01.08.09, 06:24 PM EST A pair of financially troubled Allentown companies that provide long-term care insurance are under control of the Pennsylvania ...
    Long-Term Care Insurer Penn Treaty American Fails TheStreet.com
    Penn Treaty Insurance Subsidiaries Enter Rehabilitation PR Newswire (press release)
    Pa. Takes Long-Term Care Insurer Into Rehabilitation Trading Markets (press release)
    all 21 news articles
    Blue Shield of California Restores Insurance for Patients it Dropped - Wall Street Journal Blogs

    SmartAboutHealth

    Blue Shield of California Restores Insurance for Patients it Dropped
    Wall Street Journal Blogs, NY - Jan 7, 2009
    In a bid to put to rest legal troubles over a practice of canceling patients? health insurance policies after they got sick, Blue Shield of California has ...
    Blue Shield settles with Insurance Department Bizjournals.com
    High stakes in health battle Boston Globe
    Blue Shield to restore coverage for dropped Californians Los Angeles Times
    WKBW-TV - eMaxHealth.com
    all 145 news articles
    Employees Need Health Insurance, Not Cash - The Star-Ledger - NJ.com

    The Star-Ledger - NJ.com

    Employees Need Health Insurance, Not Cash
    The Star-Ledger - NJ.com, NJ - 12 hours ago
    As business owners have become saddled with double-digit increases each year for the cost of health insurance, workers are seeing diminished policies, ...
    City gives raises in exchange for less costly health insurance Hudson Star Observer
    How Will Health Care Reform Impact the Employer-Based System? Business Finance Magazine
    Companies, workers should cooperate to lower costs Buffalo News
    all 4 news articles
    Home | Site Map | Resource Links