RPG: Table and Computer


It's not a secret that table RPG games are not so popular as they used to be. However a certain number of amateurs are still fond of them. What is so particular about a pasteboard box or a book with rules? It seems that all the advantages have their " younger computer brothers": no manual calculations, no bricks ( the number of which is from one to almost 20). In general, no additional efforts are needed- just relax, play and don't worry. But nothing of the kind- groups of maniacs with burning eyes run to the special shop( if there is any), buy another book, and having met in some dark place in the evening, start to crunch with pens and tinkle the dice.

Why are these poor things so attracted by this desperately ancient way of entertainment?

Let's try to answer this question by displaying the most similar and different features of table and computer RPG.

Firstly, any RPG is a Role Paying Game, which is supposed to have a character, and a system of his development. This feature is typical for both the "brothers". The character as the player's realization in the created RPG world is very important. Your playing capabilities depend on his features.

Secondly, any decent RPG is based on some world (sometimes, realistic but more often-fantastic one). The depth of the world ( The card details, atmosphere entirety, detailed development of the world components) and , so to say, the mood (optimistic and colorful or destructive and gloomy, funny or extremely rigid, strict),- all this taken together defines the audience of the game.

These two points have a great meaning, they allow the player to associate himself with a certain character and being in his shoes to go through the situations which are impossible in ordinary life.

All this is very good but let's return to our muttons: to the difference between computer and table RPG.

Probably, trite comparison of books and films will be to the place here. The former make us use our brains and imagination, the latter give us everything ready-made. The peculiarity of table RPG, its strong and at the same time weak point is hope for player's imagination.. In the classical table RPG you'll find a text, some illustrations and? all the rest you should imagine yourself. It's true, that during the gaming process everything depends on the leader (Dungeon Master, Game Master, etc.) and on the players. The leader explains the situation, describes the characters and the events orally (yes, he does it with the help of words!!!) and the players perceive this information judging from their abilities. What are the advantages of such a game play? They are quite evident: everyone perceives the game in his own way (with the help of his imagination), but at the same time, if the game is rather good, a special "field" of common perception and mood is formed. It's not an allegation as the author has great experience of playing table RPG and so he knows all ins and outs. When the game has a success, the players seem to be in the same "information field" and sometimes they don't even perceive the events in real life. It's just like reading a thrilling book. But sometimes such beauty turns into a terrible thing. What is so horrible about it? The trouble is, the game may be a complete failure if it's leaded by a talentless and not very experienced master, or if the players turn out to be so-so (that is less critical). In such a case the game fails no matter how beautiful the original RPG world is. Everything gets wrong when after each word the master utters: "well, eh, oh?" and it takes the players 10 minutes to think over each further act. The game reaches a deadlock, a perfect illusion is breaking into the small pieces of separate sentences.I must admit, sometimes it's all RPG developers 'fault that such failures take place, especially when the rules of the game aren't logical or overcharged with unnecessary details. May the fans forgive me, but the last time the author had to play AD&D, there was such a situation:

-Player:" I want to kill that Gobline!"

-Master: "throw the dice for marksmanship. Uph, you shoot in the darkness-that means, the fine should be taken into account. Well.. have you got the bonus? Aha?I'll find it, wait a bit? Oh?throw these three bricks on D-20,?Hmmm?where is that table? OK, we are going to count all the damages and take into account his armor and the spell and that's all!"

I don't say everything was exactly so, but on the whole-just the way I described. What absorption into fantastic world can we talk about if you have to remember 20 figures and throw the dice dozen times for each act! But not all the table games have such a disadvantage. Besides, we may ignore too "hard" rules.

Now let's analyze what we have in computer RPG.

From the first look everyt5hing is just the same-the game system, characters, the game world. But all these things are already made, you can see the picture with your eyes. Is it good or bad?

It depends. By all means, it's pleasant to see "visual" character, a charming landscape, fire from shots, etc. But your own brains don't work any longer since there's no necessity in it. Besides, we won't see "our own world". We perceive things as they should be from the game developers' point of view. Their way of perception becomes ours as well. You will never be able to see the world with your own eyes and make the character really yours, no matter how hard the developers tried to improve the game. Such a situation has two consequences:

1) Tragic one: your imagination is completely blocked and you don't like the others' vision.( such a situation is typical for the most of projects).

2) Pleasant one: some painters and designers create real masterpieces and we can't but admire their world vision ( here you perfectly understand the difference between your plain brains and a talented professional's work).

But are there many games like that in the second point? Frankly speaking, I know only one-Fallout. And I appreciate not the graphics but amazing style, exact place of every button, picture, character.

Let's also mention incontestable advantage of computer RPG. It deals with those calculations which make so many table RPG boring. Computer will calculate all the fines, bonuses and character's features in a flash. Strange as it may seem but computer games are based just on the table systems and the developers of the former ones don't aim to overcharge machines with numerous correlations and parameters.

At last we've come to a very sensitive problem of the computer RPG- opportunities provided in the game. Sometimes playing RPG on the computer you may suddenly want to act the way not offered by the plot of the game. ( to look into the hatch which is pictured on the background or to take the car you are not allowed to). I am sure that such things are familiar to every gamer. It's great if the plot and the locations are well considered. And what if they are not ( as it happens more often)? We must admit that the developers of computer games are constantly improving the gamer's opportunities in the installed worlds. But if the direction is not perfect, the game turns into hard work and it makes the player take advantage of all the improvements (even if he is not willing to).

Table RPG is another matter: the action there is equal to one word, no talks linearity ( you can communicate with the leader the way you like), no plot linearity ( you can do what you like until you are killed). Full freedom of the decisions and actions provided by table RPG will never be substituted by any perfect program. Here you can act as you like.Besides, the standard of the game can be easily changed. For example, I can tell you from my own experience that once I started the game as a guard (pure RPG adventure) and finished as an emperor (RPG+tactics+strategy).

That's it.

It's for you to judge what is better. What and how to play is also for you. But I'd like to say (from my own experience again) that table RPG develop our brains while computer ones don't.

A friend of mine being an active table player suddenly began reading books( he didn't use to do it since his childhood). He started to read not classical masterpieces or since fiction. That was fantasy. But anyway he began READING, and that's the point.

Another my friend got used to computer and became a real fan and gamer. Now I constantly see black areas under his eyes and our communication is bothered by a turned on PC.

Of course, these are separate examples and the author must admit, he is addicted to computer RPG . But nevertheless it's table RPG which gives us the opportunity to communicate and improve. That 's what all the author's life experience tells about.

P.S. I'm ready to an open discussion of the topic. You are free to write your thoughts to me.

By the way, an interesting question: does anybody see the opportunity to combine the two kinds of RPG described above? What if there is the golden mean? What if there is?

About the Author
Efimov Peter is a game designer of White Elephant, a great collection of shareware games. Please, visit his site http://www.elephant-games.com for only best games for you and your children!





Latest News:



Site: Yahoo! News Search Results for news
News Corp says Mark Williams interim Premiere CEO (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
News Corp. executive Mark Williams has taken over as chief executive of German pay-TV broadcaster Premiere in an interim capacity, News Corp. said after the move led to renewed takeover speculation. News Corp. says Mark Williams interim Premiere CEO (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
Mark Williams, a News Corp. executive named late on Wednesday as chief executive of German pay-TV broadcaster Premiere, has taken over in an interim capacity, a News Corp. spokeswoman said on Thursday. Column: Palin's Nomination Good News Even For Democrats In Alaska (CBS News)
So, John McCain picked Sarah Palin to be his running mate. Let me just say, wow. That's not exactly what I repeatedly shouted out when I first heard the news, but it's close enough for publication. Like everyone else, my astonished reaction wasn't due to the event itself being inconceivable - I've heard pundits debating the likelihood of a McCain / Palin ticket for months. Premiere CEO Is Replaced by News Corp.'s Williams (Update2) (Bloomberg.com)
Sept. 10 (Bloomberg) -- Premiere AG , the German pay- television company partly owned by News Corp., said Chief Executive Officer Michael Boernicke is being replaced by a senior News Corp. executive. News Corp exec becomes chief of Germany's Premiere (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
News Corp's chief financial officer for Europe and Asia has been named chief executive of German pay television group Premiere, following the resignation of Michael Boernicke, Premiere said on Wednesday. Phila. mayor to announce grim budget news (Philly.com)
The Nutter administration is expected to announce grim budget news today, which is all but certain to lead to significant spending cuts - perhaps as high as 10 percent - in some city departments, according to three sources familiar with the budget. News Corporation to redevelop London Wapping site (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
Rupert Murdoch's News Corporation is to redevelop its Wapping site in London, moving all its UK businesses, including News International, Harper Collins, MySpace and Dow Jones, under one roof. Tribune blames Google for damaging news story (Market Watch)
SAN FRANCISCO (MarketWatch) -- Tribune Co. said Wednesday that the mistaken online publishing of an old news story that cratered UAL Corp.'s stock price earlier this week was because of a repeated technology failure at Google Inc. DeJesus, Royals sad at Sweeney news (MLB.com)
DeJesus, Royals sad at Sweeney news Six-year-old story pops up on Google News, triggering United Airlines share price collapse (Tech Digest via Yahoo! UK & Ireland News)
Three cheers for automated technology! The Google News "Googlebot" search routine decided last weekend that a six-year-old story regarding United Airlines filing for bankruptcy was new and exciting.

Site: news - Google News
New Voices in Congress Will Change the Tone of the Democratic Majority - New York Times

USA Today

New Voices in Congress Will Change the Tone of the Democratic Majority
New York Times, United States - 16 hours ago
The latest on the presidential transition and other political news from Washington and around the nation. Join the discussion. ...
Video: Burris Reflects on His Trip to Washington AssociatedPress
New Senate takes shape - with 2 missing pieces Boston Globe
Power, pop, and probings from ABC News Senior White House ... ABC News
The Associated Press - USA Today
all 9,912 news articles
Ballmer touts Windows 7 beta, new deals - CNET News

New York Times

Ballmer touts Windows 7 beta, new deals
CNET News, CA - 5 hours ago
Microsoft will also announce new deals for Windows Live that will see Microsoft's search engine become the default on PCs from Dell as well as touting a ...
Windows Live Essentials released, more Windows Live news from CES LiveSide
Cheat sheet: Microsoft's CES keynote news in a nutshell TechFlash
Microsoft's Ballmer touts new Windows, search deal MarketWatch
CNBC - PC World India
all 632 news articles
Amid Gaza violence, a new task for Obama - USA Today

WELT ONLINE

Amid Gaza violence, a new task for Obama
USA Today - 2 hours ago
Instead, the new spate of violence "will empower every anti-Israel, anti-US and extremist movement in the Middle East and the Islamic world," says Anthony ...
Video: Gaza Gets a Brief Break AssociatedPress
News Analysis: How far to Gaza ceasefire? Xinhua
AP Top News at 10:08 am EST The Associated Press
Philadelphia Inquirer - World Socialist Web Site
all 28,112 news articles
Australia, New Zealand Dollars Drop on Commodities, US Jobs - Bloomberg

Hürriyet

Australia, New Zealand Dollars Drop on Commodities, US Jobs
Bloomberg - 2 hours ago
8 (Bloomberg) -- The Australian and New Zealand currencies fell, snapping three days of gains versus the US dollar, as prices of commodities that make up ...
Currencies Trading All Over the Map Washington Post
Australia, New Zealand Dollars Drop on Commodities, US Jobs Bloomberg
Dollar Near 5-Week High After GM Says May Not Need More Funds Bloomberg
Bloomberg
all 372 news articles
Phil Schiller bringing the news at Macworld - San Francisco Chronicle

BBC News

Phil Schiller bringing the news at Macworld
San Francisco Chronicle,  USA - 8 hours ago
We get going at 9 am and we'll be delivering the news as it happens. 8:53 am Just a few minutes away. Listened to some Killers music on the way in. ...
Video: Steve Jobs Weight Loss Due to Hormone Imbalance AssociatedPress
Apple disappoints: No Jobs or big news at Macworld Reuters
Apple announces new iTunes prices and an 8-hour laptop battery San Jose Mercury News
PC World - New Zealand Herald
all 2,810 news articles
New Sony Hard-Drive HD Camcorders - PC World

PC World

New Sony Hard-Drive HD Camcorders
PC World - 8 hours ago
The SR line will live on, however, with three new standard-definition units. Pictured above is the Sony Handycam HDR-XR520V ($1500, available in March). ...
New Sony Camcorders Do GPS, Too PC World
Sony Unleashes 60X-Optical-Zoom Camcorders PC World
Sony's First Flash-Based Camcorders PC World
all 43 news articles
AMD introduces Dragon PC gaming platform and new Phenom II CPUs - CNET News

CNET News

AMD introduces Dragon PC gaming platform and new Phenom II CPUs
CNET News, CA - 3 hours ago
The big news with Dragon is really the Phenom II chips. Available as the 3.0GHz Phenom II X4 940 and the 2.8GHz Phenom II X4 920, these new quad-core CPUs ...
Madoff, SocGen, Sun Pharma, Axel Springer, Apple in Court News - Bloomberg

Madoff, SocGen, Sun Pharma, Axel Springer, Apple in Court News
Bloomberg - 2 hours ago
Madoff, 08-mag-2735, US District Court, Southern District of New York (Manhattan). Jerome Kerviel, blamed by Societe Generale SA for its record trading loss ...
Samberg?s Pequot Said to Face New SEC Insider-Trading Inquiry - Bloomberg

Samberg?s Pequot Said to Face New SEC Insider-Trading Inquiry
Bloomberg - 2 hours ago
8 (Bloomberg) -- The US Securities and Exchange Commission opened a new investigation into whether Pequot Capital Management Inc., the hedge fund run by ...
Hedge fund Pequot faces new SEC probe - Bloomberg Reuters
all 12 news articles
Sony Ericsson's new W508 Walkman phone - CNET News

CNET News

Sony Ericsson's new W508 Walkman phone
CNET News, CA - 7 hours ago
Sony Ericsson expanded its Walkman phone line at CES with the announcement of its new W508 music phone. Sporting a flip phone design that reminds us of the ...

MORE RESOURCES:
Site: Yahoo! News Search Results for games
Cubs-Astros games postponed because of Ike (AP via Yahoo! News)

The first two games of this weekend's series between the Chicago Cubs and Houston Astros have been postponed because of the potential impact of Hurricane Ike. Video games sales rise 9 pct in August: NPD (Reuters via Yahoo! News)

U.S. video games sales rose 9 percent in August from a year earlier, marking the smallest monthly sales increase in more than two years, according to data from research firm NPD on Thursday. Models reveal 'geology of Games' (BBC News)

Decades of data are turned into 3D graphics of what lies beneath the 2014 Commonwealth Games host city. Cubs-Astros games postponed due to hurricane (Fox Sports)

The first two games of this weekend's series between the Chicago Cubs and Houston Astros have been postponed because of the potential impact of Hurricane Ike. Baseball officials also were anticipating that Sunday's series finale also might be postponed. One of the scenarios under consideration was to play a doubleheader Monday, and make up the third game on Sept. 29 if it's needed to decide a ... Verizon Wireless Releases Dozens Of Games From 10 Publishers (paidContent.org via Yahoo! Finance)

It's all about games today for Verizon Wireless . The carrier released dozens of mobile games from 10 publishers. Gameloft , Glu Mobile , Konami Digital Entertainment, Mobitween, Namco Networks, RealNetworks , SkyZone Entertainment, Smashing Ideas, Capcom Interactive and Sony Pictures Television all teamed up with the carrier to launch games such as The Dark Knight and Sally's Salon. Cubs-Astros Games Postponed Because of Ike (ABC News)

Cubs-Astros games Friday and Saturday postponed because of Hurricane Ike Ike threat postpones first 2 games of Cubs-'Stros (CBS Sportsline)

The first two games of this weekend's series between the Cubs and Astros have been postponed because of the potential impact of Hurricane Ike. Cubs-Astros games postponed because of Ike (Chicago Tribune)

Houston owner Drayton McLane is holding out hope the two Cubs-Astros games postponed because of Hurricane Ike can be played Sunday and Monday at Minute Maid Park. But Lou Piniella? "Unless this thing totally bypasses the Houston area, I don't know how you can get into Houston, or if they had to get out, how they would get out." Central update: Brewers at Phillies on Thursday RosenBlog: Cubs' ... Ike postpones two Cubs-Astros games (MLB.com)

Two Cubs-Astros games postponed Can the Games Usher in New Era for China's Disabled? (Time.com via Yahoo! News)

As the host nation's athletes continue to gather golds at the 2008 Paralympics, many in Beijing hope the Games will open doors for China's other 83 million disabled citizens Site: games - Google News
Will OU's video-game offensive numbers add up to 1? - Dallas Morning News

Washington Post

Will OU's video-game offensive numbers add up to 1?
Dallas Morning News, TX - 3 hours ago
The 60-point binges, the 702 total points, the 562.1 yards per game ? they were real, all right. They'll make the record books. But were they the base of a ...
BCS title game analysis Kansas City Star
Settling the BCS Los Angeles Times
What to watch for tonight: Oklahoma's offense vs. Florida's speedy ... San Jose Mercury News
International Herald Tribune - San Francisco Chronicle
all 1,523 news articles
Senators? Ruutu Penalized 2 Games for Biting - New York Times

Canoe.ca

Senators? Ruutu Penalized 2 Games for Biting
New York Times, United States - 6 hours ago
By AP The National Hockey League suspended Ottawa Senators forward Jarkko Ruutu for two games on Wednesday for biting Buffalo Sabres left wing Andrew Peters ...
Senators' Ruutu Gets Two-Game Suspension Hartford Courant
Senators' Ruutu suspended for biting Baltimore Sun
Ruutu suspended two games for biting guardian.co.uk
hockeyfights.com - Buffalo News
all 714 news articles
Yao's Back, but It's T-Mac's Team Now - Washington Post

Washington Post

Yao's Back, but It's T-Mac's Team Now
Washington Post, United States - 5 hours ago
Six players scored in double figures for the Rockets, who ended a two-game skid and won for just the second time in six games. Shane Battier had 15 points, ...
The sky is falling: Rockets hand Celtics another loss Seattle Post Intelligencer
Rockets-Celtics Preview USA Today
Around the NBA: Celtics fall at home San Jose Mercury News
Boston Globe - Detroit Free Press
all 1,199 news articles
Baltimore native puts aside hometown feelings - Baltimore Sun

Washington Post

Baltimore native puts aside hometown feelings
Baltimore Sun, United States - 37 minutes ago
In 2007, he returned interceptions for touchdowns in back-to-back games. This season, he twice tied for the team lead in passes defended. ...
Ravens-Titans a defensive struggle The Associated Press
Ed Reed Being Ed Reed and Other Topics New York Times
Titans offensive line turning Kerry Collins into a statue USA Today
My Tennessean.com - Baltimore Sun
all 1,279 news articles
NFC Divisional playoffs to feature rematches - Houston Chronicle

New York Daily News

NFC Divisional playoffs to feature rematches
Houston Chronicle, United States - 1 hour ago
No one will be lacking familiarity in the NFL playoff games this weekend, especially in the NFC. All four games this weekend are rematches, including the ...
After being benched, Donovan McNabb has Eagles soaring New York Daily News
Eagles-Giants game is a tough call Cherry Hill Courier Post
Eagles' game plan up in air Press of Atlantic City
Newsday - Kansas City Star
all 696 news articles
BCS national championship game preview - Austin American-Statesman

New York Daily News

BCS national championship game preview
Austin American-Statesman, TX - 3 hours ago
Heisman-winning QB Sam Bradford (led nation in QB rating, 25 TD passes, 1 INT in last seven games) must not only fight Heisman jinx (Heisman QBs are 2-5 in ...
KINNEY: Trash-talking part of big games Moore American
Quarterbacks at center of BCS championship game Philadelphia Daily News
HOW OKLAHOMA GOT HERE Tampa Tribune
MiamiHerald.com - International Herald Tribune
all 662 news articles
Offense is Steelers' defense mechanism - Los Angeles Times

New York Times

Offense is Steelers' defense mechanism
Los Angeles Times, CA - 4 hours ago
The Chargers were limited to 218 yards and quarterback Philip Rivers had one of his worst games of the season, throwing for 164 yards with two interceptions ...
Big Ben needs a bigger helmet San Diego Union Tribune
RB Tomlinson doubtful for playoff game Denver Post
Steelers look to jump start offense as they host Chargers again NFL News
The Associated Press - USA Today
all 1,257 news articles
Wolves' victory means rare air -- a three-game streak - Minneapolis Star Tribune

Washington Post

Wolves' victory means rare air -- a three-game streak
Minneapolis Star Tribune, MN - 3 hours ago
But ONE GAME AT A TIME Up next: 7 tonight vs. Oklahoma City ? Target Center ? TV: FSN (1130-AM) MEMPHIS - Two years ago at this time, Randy Foye was a ...
Minnesota welcomes Thunder to town Seattle Post Intelligencer
Oklahoma City USA Today
Foye, Wolves keep rolling over Thunder The Associated Press
Minneapolis Star Tribune - Seattle Post Intelligencer
all 405 news articles
Dallas Mavericks have lacked focus in last two games - Dallas Morning News

Bleacher Report

Dallas Mavericks have lacked focus in last two games
Dallas Morning News, TX - 8 hours ago
"We've had two bad games in a row," Jason Terry said. "We were fortunate to get away with a win." "That's part of it," he said. ...
Dallas Mavericks letting NBA know about no-calls Fort Worth Star Telegram
Eric Gordon: an NBA rookie on the rise Indianapolis Star
Knicks at Mavericks Spread, Odds, Trends & Matchups The Spread
ESPN - USA Today
all 139 news articles
Cards shaking off franchise's haunted past in playoff run - USA Today

TheOnlinewire

Cards shaking off franchise's haunted past in playoff run
USA Today - 3 hours ago
"We're trying to become mentally tougher like the Giants did last year and not let those things (road games) bother us." Whisenhunt sold management on ...
Boldin sits out practice again; status unclear Arizona Republic
Cardinals hope to break East Coast jinx in rematch with Panthers NFL News
Dave Albee: LaBoy vs. McCoy puts Marin spin on NFL playoff game Marin Independent-Journal
Winston-Salem Journal - Bleacher Report
all 640 news articles
Home | Site Map | Resource Links