Medium and the Message


A debate is raging in e-publishing circles: should content be encrypted and protected (the Barnes and Noble or Digital goods model) - or should it be distributed freely and thus serve as a form of viral marketing (Seth Godin's "ideavirus")? Publishers fear that freely distributed and cost-free "cracked" e-books will cannibalize print books to oblivion.

The more paranoid point at the music industry. It failed to co-opt the emerging peer-to-peer platforms (Napster) and to offer a viable digital assets management system with an equitable sharing of royalties. The results? A protracted legal battle and piracy run amok. "Publishers" - goes this creed - "are positioned to incorporate encryption and protection measures at the very inception of the digital publishing industry. They ought to learn the lesson."

But this view ignores a vital difference between sound and text. In music, what matter are the song or the musical piece. The medium (or carrier, or packing) is marginal and interchangeable. A CD, an audio cassette, or an MP3 player are all fine, as far as the consumer is concerned. The listener bases his or her purchasing decisions on sound quality and the faithfulness of reproduction of the listening experience (for instance, in a concert hall). This is a very narrow, rational, measurable and quantifiable criterion.

Not so with text.

Content is only one element of many of equal footing underlying the decision to purchase a specific text-"carrier" (medium). Various media encapsulating IDENTICAL text will still fare differently. Hence the failure of CD-ROMs and e-learning. People tend to consume content in other formats or media, even if it is fully available to them or even owned by them in one specific medium. People prefer to pay to listen to live lectures rather than read freely available online transcripts. Libraries buy print journals even when they have subscribed to the full text online versions of the very same publications. And consumers overwhelmingly prefer to purchase books in print rather than their e-versions.

This is partly a question of the slow demise of old habits. E-books have yet to develop the user-friendliness, platform-independence, portability, brows ability and many other attributes of this ingenious medium, the Gutenberg tome. But it also has to do with marketing psychology. Where text (or text equivalents, such as speech) is concerned, the medium is at least as important as the message. And this will hold true even when e-books catch up with their print brethren technologically.

There is no doubting that finally e-books will surpass print books as a medium and offer numerous options: hyperlinks within the e-book and without it - to web content, reference works, etc., embedded instant shopping and ordering links, divergent, user-interactive, decision driven plotlines, interaction with other e-books (using Bluetooth or another wireless standard), collaborative authoring, gaming and community activities, automatically or periodically updated content, ,multimedia capabilities, database, Favourites and History Maintenance (records of reading habits, shopping habits, interaction with other readers, plot related decisions and much more), automatic and embedded audio conversion and translation capabilities, full wireless piconetworking and scatternetworking capabilities and more.

The same textual content will be available in the future in various media. Ostensibly, consumers should gravitate to the feature-rich and much cheaper e-book. But they won't - because the medium is as important as the text message. It is not enough to own the same content, or to gain access to the same message. Ownership of the right medium does count. Print books offer connectivity within an historical context (tradition). E-books are cold and impersonal, alienated and detached. The printed word offers permanence. Digital text is ephemeral (as anyone whose writings perished in the recent dot.com bloodbath or Deja takeover by Google can attest). Printed volumes are a whole sensorium, a sensual experience - olfactory and tactile and visual. E-books are one dimensional in comparison. These are differences that cannot be overcome, not even with the advent of digital "ink" on digital "paper". They will keep the print book alive and publishers' revenues flowing.

People buy printed matter not merely because of its content. If this were true e-books will have won the day. Print books are a packaged experience, the substance of life. People buy the medium as often and as much as they buy the message it encapsulates. It is impossible to compete with this mistique. Safe in this knowledge, publishers should let go and impose on e-books "encryption" and "protection" levels as rigorous as they do on the their print books. The latter are here to stay alongside the former. With the proper pricing and a modicum of trust, e-books may even end up promoting the old and trusted print versions.

About The Author

Sam Vaknin is the author of "Malignant Self Love - Narcissism Revisited" and "After the Rain - How the West Lost the East". He is a columnist in "Central Europe Review", United Press International (UPI) and ebookweb.org and the editor of mental health and Central East Europe categories in The Open Directory, Suite101 and searcheurope.com. Until recently, he served as the Economic Advisor to the Government of Macedonia.

His web site: http://samvak.tripod.com





Latest News:



Site: Yahoo! News Search Results for news
JCDecaux in talks for News Outdoor Group in Russia (AP via Yahoo! News)
French outdoor advertising firm JCDecaux SA said Thursday it is negotiating to buy Russian rival News Outdoor Group from global media company News Corp. News Corp tightens grip on Premiere with new CEO (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
Rupert Murdoch tightened his grip on German pay-TV broadcaster Premiere by appointing News Corp executive Mark Williams as CEO in a move to get the company back on track. JCDecaux and News Corp. in talks to combine outdoor ad groups (International Herald Tribune)
The News Corp. chief executive, Rupert Murdoch, has recently expressed nervousness about investments in Russia, where News Outdoor generated the bulk of its revenue last year. News Corp says Mark Williams interim Premiere CEO (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
News Corp. executive Mark Williams has taken over as chief executive of German pay-TV broadcaster Premiere in an interim capacity, News Corp. said after the move led to renewed takeover speculation. News Corp. says Mark Williams interim Premiere CEO (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
Mark Williams, a News Corp. executive named late on Wednesday as chief executive of German pay-TV broadcaster Premiere, has taken over in an interim capacity, a News Corp. spokeswoman said on Thursday. JCDecaux in talks to buy News Corp. billboard unit (AP via Yahoo! Finance)
In a deal that would create the world's largest outdoor advertising company, French conglomerate JCDecaux SA said Thursday that it is in talks to buy Russian rival News Outdoor Group from global media company News Corp. Weekly world news quiz (BBC News)
At the end of another week, test your knowledge with our world news quiz. UPI NewsTrack Entertainment News (UPI)
Kanye arrested in paparazzi scuffle ... Report: Critic smacked Ebert with binder ... Cafe Tacvba nominated for 6 Latin Grammys ... Groban to perform TV songs at Emmys ... News from United Press International. United shares climb after news debacle (UPI)
CHICAGO, Sept. 11 (UPI) -- A computer program assigning dates to news stories was partly to blame for a sell-off of United Airlines stock Monday, a Google spokesman said. JCDecaux in talks for News Outdoor Group in Russia (San Francisco Chronicle)
French outdoor advertising firm JCDecaux SA said Thursday it is negotiating to buy Russian rival News Outdoor Group from global media company News Corp. In a statement, the global seller of outdoor advertising said it was in exclusive talks with Rupert...

Site: news - Google News
News roundup: Cool reception for automakers on Capitol Hill - USA Today

News roundup: Cool reception for automakers on Capitol Hill
USA Today - 1 hour ago
And Congress, as a whole, is suffering from acute bailout fatigue," according to The New York Times. CNN says economists are concerned that the nation's ...
US & World News, 12/05 WTVW
Today's News | Christian Views World Magazine
Thursday's News Recap: BOE and ECB Chop Rates, Canadian Parliament ... CEP News
Forbes - Dayton Daily News
all 992 news articles
CNET News Daily Podcast: Facebook, Google open competing services - CNET News

CNET News

CNET News Daily Podcast: Facebook, Google open competing services
CNET News, CA - 16 hours ago
A new Firefox plug-in turns Amazon.com into piracy heaven for people looking to download music, movies, and other digital content for free. ...
The SFGate friends Facebook San Francisco Chronicle
Networking News American Journalism Review
Facebook Pushes New Service Wall Street Journal
CRN - Mashable
all 215 news articles
Research and Markets: AirGuide Business Provides Comprehensive ... - MarketWatch

Research and Markets: AirGuide Business Provides Comprehensive ...
MarketWatch - 2 hours ago
Comprehensive weekly news on the world's airlines, airports, aircraft manufacturers and suppliers, aerospace, defense, space, including car rental, hotels, ...
McClatchy News VP Howard Weaver to Retire - MarketWatch

McClatchy News VP Howard Weaver to Retire
MarketWatch - 22 hours ago
who twice led the Anchorage Daily News to Pulitzer Prize gold medals for public service, has announced his retirement at the end of the year. ...
News Analysis Campaign Promises on Ending the War in Iraq Now ... - New York Times

Voice of America

News Analysis Campaign Promises on Ending the War in Iraq Now ...
New York Times, United States - 17 hours ago
31, 2011, date for sending the rest of American troops home that is spelled out in the new agreement between the United States and the Iraqi government. ...
Even if Obama pulls out of Iraq, thousands of troops may remain Chicago Tribune
THAT NOISE IS MY HEAD HITTING MY DESK. Tapped
all 295 news articles
Movie news | ?Terminator: Salvation,? ?Godfather II,? ?Twilight ... - Kansas City Star

Movie news | ?Terminator: Salvation,? ?Godfather II,? ?Twilight ...
Kansas City Star, MO - 4 hours ago
But which new film will make the most money this weekend? Our predictions and our records through eight weeks: ?Movies editor Robert W. Butler (4-4), ...
Obama answers Fox News question - Examiner.com

WELT ONLINE

Obama answers Fox News question
Examiner.com - 1 hour ago
President-elect Barack Obama has called on a Fox News Channel reporter in a press conference. As we told you earlier this week, FNC was batting zero in five ...
Video: Hispanics Look To Obama CBS
New Mexico News Brief, Thursday, Dec. 4 KOAT
BEHIND THE NEWS: All in the Cabinet 7Online.com
Wall Street Journal Blogs - International Herald Tribune
all 3,073 news articles
Scripps to Seek Buyer for Rocky Mountain News - MarketWatch

The Inquisitr

Scripps to Seek Buyer for Rocky Mountain News
MarketWatch - 20 hours ago
Scripps bought the Rocky Mountain News, which is Colorado's first newspaper and the state's oldest continuously operated business, in 1926. ...
Scripps puts Rocky Mountain News up for sale The Associated Press
Rocky Mountain News Up for Sale Examiner.com
Rocky Mountain News Is Put Up for Sale After Loss New York Times Blogs
Denver Post - The Colorado Independent
all 307 news articles
PRESS DIGEST - New York Times business news - Dec 5 - Forbes

PRESS DIGEST - New York Times business news - Dec 5
Forbes, NY - 9 hours ago
Dec 5 (Reuters) - The following were the top stories in the New York Times business pages on Friday. Reuters has not verified these stories and does not ...
Stocks Plunge on Layoff News - Washington Post

MSN Money UK

Stocks Plunge on Layoff News
Washington Post, United States - 9 hours ago
It fell to $43.67 a barrel on the New York Mercantile Exchange, its lowest level since 2005. Already down 60 percent from its peak of $147 billion a barrel ...
Stocks Rally Despite Grim Data Washington Post
all 16 news articles

MORE RESOURCES:
Site: Yahoo! News Search Results for ezine publishing
Site: ezine publishing - Google News
Online Home Business Marketing: Five Newer Marketing Tactics and ... - PowerHomeBiz.com (press release)

Online Home Business Marketing: Five Newer Marketing Tactics and ...
PowerHomeBiz.com (press release) - Nov 21, 2008
Writing and submitting articles to ezine publishers, website owners and article directories is still one of the best ways to build your business. ...
Top 3 Ways To Boost Your Affiliate Commissions Overnight - Best Syndication

Best Syndication

Top 3 Ways To Boost Your Affiliate Commissions Overnight
Best Syndication, CA - Nov 23, 2008
Publish an online newsletter or Ezine. It is always best to recommend a product to someone you know than to sell to a stranger. This is the purpose behind ...
A Sure-fire, 10-step Formula to Get Started as a Coach or Consultant - Melodika.net

A Sure-fire, 10-step Formula to Get Started as a Coach or Consultant
Melodika.net, Bulgaria - Nov 21, 2008
Oh, I guess that would be step six and a half - start your ezine! It's so simple to do, there is just no excuse not to have one. ...
Deconstructing the Orthodox - CP Aboobacker in Conversation - Desicritics.org

Deconstructing the Orthodox - CP Aboobacker in Conversation
Desicritics.org, India - Nov 23, 2008
On very few occasions, the ezines are forced to publish some lower level works. But it happens in print media too. But e-publishing must be encouraged while ...
Internet Marketing Methods To Attract Targeted Website Traffic - American Chronicle

Internet Marketing Methods To Attract Targeted Website Traffic
American Chronicle, CA - Nov 12, 2008
Here are a few of the best article directories on the internet that you can submit your articles to: Buzzle, Ezine Articles, ArticlesBase, Article City, ...
Home | Site Map | Resource Links