Reading to Children - Are We Doing It Right?


Setting the Stage - Reading is One of the Big Boosts to Life:

Several studies over several years in several settings have all shown a high correlation between reading to young children and academic competence throughout their traditional school years. We all know by now that reading stories to a child is an important part of the child's early development, and so we read to them. Some parents read because they enjoy passing along the good feelings they remember or sense they had as a child. Others read to their young children because they have heard it's a good thing to do. Still others do it to calm an agitated baby. And then there are those who don't see the point. The intention of this article is to get you to think about what might be happening inside the child as you approach your reading time together, and see if there might be something that could improve this quality time you are investing in each other.

The Problem:

The problem with reading to young children is that the available material is often pretty boring to us, the readers. This often makes the actual reading kind of a chore for us. Compounding this problem is the fact that young children, and almost everyone else, can tell when you're faking it. When you put these facts together, unless you are exceptionally gifted or fortunate, your children are probably learning all about faking it along with whatever academic preparation they're getting out of your reading. Or worse, they're getting the idea that reading is boring. It's difficult to tell exactly what's going on in their heads at this stage, but I have to imagine there's a little of both mixing it up in their developing synapses.

So, how do we address these potential problems?

There are two approaches:

APPROACH # 1: Work on the symptoms (Don't feel bad, this is what almost everyone does) - Over-animate with your voice and pump yourself up for the ordeal - similar to sales preparation and self-hypnosis. This is actually a pretty good form of compensation and can effectively mask the boredom. The challenge is in making the boring material come alive through animation. If you can pull this off consistently, you'll be okay. Another "mask the symptom" approach is to improvise to the point that the story becomes interesting to you. This takes a Robin Williams kind of personality, and most people will not be able to sustain this with any level of competence over the long haul. The last "bandaid" is to read it like you see it - make reading a bedtime activity and use it to bore the child to sleep. This may have unpredictable consequences later on, but it has been demonstrated to be far better than not reading to the child at all.

APPROACH # 2: Work on the root cause: Select material that you like - not in terms of subject matter necessarily, but in terms of rhythm or clever word construction or fun, off-the-wall logic. It's out there, but you do have to search for it. Select material that helps you recover some of the perspective of your audience and use it as a launching pad to get you "into" their level of joy and sensation. Another approach to chip away at the root cause of the problem is to write your own material to your own standards. Don't be afraid to try this. You won't do any worse than most of the published children's authors.

The Scope of the Solution:

Since the root cause of the problem is boring material, we need to find more stimulating material that would also be of interest to children who are beginning to understand our language. Ideally, it would be nice to find material that makes some sense, caters to a child's view, is well illustrated, has short sentences, has appropriate vocabulary, and helps us connect with the child's view of life. This can be somewhat tricky, but it is not impossible.

Elements of the Solution - Perspective:

From the child's point of view, anything that interests you that is prose will work before the age of about 6 months (not chemical engineering textbooks). At this point, developmentally, the child is still getting his bearings, and any audio he gets is useful input to his little computer that is sorting through the intricacies of language at a frightening pace. After this age, it is probably wise to start selecting stories that a child with 6+ months of experience might relate to, from his experiential perspective, so he can become interested in the subject matter as his comprehension skills adjust to the task. I'm talking about stories iwth short sentences that are loaded with vivid, age-appropriate sensory descriptions and common objects that can be found below the 2-foot level. It might be useful for you to walk around with a video camera strapped to a stick that can be easily moved around a foot off the ground, and watch the resulting video to see what your target audience is seeing, and how they're seeing it. You'll be surprised to see how much structural engineering they are recording. This exercise can give you a standard by which to judge the material you think might fit your audience.

Examples - both good and bad:

Think about the stories you remember and enjoyed from your childhood. There probably aren't very many. For the younger set, the Dr. Seuss collection (Cat in the Hat, Green Eggs and Ham, Oh Say Can You Say, etc.) seems to be a consistent winner. The rhythm, rhyming and surprises keep the stories moving, the sentences are short, the ideas are simple, and the length of the stories is just about right for the content. The plots and conclusions are sometimes a little quirky, but hey, maybe that's part of the magic. For the same group of young children, The Very Hungry Caterpillar is a good choice. This is what I refer to as a gimmick book - but this one is particularly good in that the sentences and page pauses make it especially easy to animate, and the pictures are big and colorful. Besides that, the gimmick is actually relevant to the story. Very well done. This is my article, so I can interject a personal opinion now and then.

Fairy tales are a special case, and probably depend more on your personal memories than on any "gold standard". The abridged versions of Cinderella, Beauty and the Beast and Sleeping Beauty seem to be good ones, in spite of the somewhat unfamiliar concepts of witches and fairy godmothers. On the other hand, Little Red Riding Hood has so many violations of common sense and such serious implications of parental abandonment that responsible adults would run from that story. Of course, that assumes the parents are paying attention, which goes back to my original thesis of boredom being a problem. I can go either way on The Three Little Pigs, but your children must be familiar with the "Huff, and Puff" segments to be accepted later in social settings, and those same segments do make for a great and memorable animation opportunity.

Recommendation for Fairy Tales: Confine the stupid ones to the 0-6-month-old set so they can have the benefit of cultural familiarity, but switch over to the more "palatable" selections when comprehension starts to become evident.

As the child gets a little older, Alexander and the Terrible, Horrible, No Good, Very Bad Day seems to work well. Good perspective, appropriate word choices, fun, long enough to get comfortable, but short enough to stay interesting, and with subjects children can relate to. This is actually close to the ideal children's book, if there is such a thing. A very interesting example is The Giving Tree. This story is pretty good for children because of its style, emotions and vocabulary, even though it involves some fairly complex and abstract emotions that are outside the scope of their experience. These emotions are handled in a way that makes the story work for all ages. Pure Genius.

Closing Comments: You are in charge. You are the absolute selection authority for your children. You must take responsibility in the use of this authority you have and make informed selections. You control how boring, inappropriate or insane the material is that you are willing to deal with yourself and subsequently transfer to your children. Conversely, you control how exciting, interesting, and profitable this selection is also. Then you inflect all the excitement you feel for the material through your animation. After the critical selection and inflection phases, the only thing left for you to do is to pay attention to how the material is written and read it with the rhythm that the author was humming in his head when he wrote the story (if rhythm is a part of the content).

Kent Walters is a veteran of reading to his own four children from an early age. He is educated in languages and linguistics, with an emphasis in the linguistic foundations of mental orientation and understanding. He is passionate about the benefits of reading to children, and is on a crusade to raise awareness and encourage this behavior in all parents. As a part of this crusade, Mr. Walters has deployed a couple of websites to encourage the review and generation of more quality children's books. He has written a few children's books himself, one of which he gives away as a free sample on his websites, http://www.reading-to-children.com and http://www.kidsstuffnews.com

This article courtesy of http://www.reading-to-children.com and http://www.kidsstuffnews.com

You may freely reprint this article on your website or in your newsletter provided this courtesy notice and the author name and URL remain intact.





Latest News:



Site: Yahoo! News Search Results for news
Myanmar's Suu Kyi to get family letters, news mags (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
Detained Myanmar opposition leader Aung San Suu Kyi has managed to wring small concessions from the ruling generals in the form of letters from her family and some international news magazines, her lawyer said on Friday. SEC Looks Into UAL Stock Scare; Implications For Online News? (CBS News)
A ton of digits have been devoted to this in other spots but the SEC's decision to investigate takes it to another level. The backstory: a six-year-old news story about UAL declaring bankruptcy made it into the Tribune-owned Sun-Sentinel 's current news flow, was picked up by a Google (NSDQ: GOOG) News bot and, via a reporter for a newsletter, made it onto Bloomberg News. After a lot of buck ... JCDecaux in talks for News Outdoor Group in Russia (AP via Yahoo! News)
French outdoor advertising firm JCDecaux SA said Thursday it is negotiating to buy Russian rival News Outdoor Group from global media company News Corp. News Corp tightens grip on Premiere with new CEO (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
Rupert Murdoch tightened his grip on German pay-TV broadcaster Premiere by appointing News Corp executive Mark Williams as CEO in a move to get the company back on track. Phila. mayor to announce grim budget news (The Philadelphia Inquirer)
The Nutter administration is expected to announce grim budget news today, which is all but certain to lead to significant spending cuts - perhaps as high as 10 percent - in some city departments, according to three sources familiar with the budget. JCDecaux and News Corp. in talks to combine outdoor ad groups (International Herald Tribune)
The News Corp. chief executive, Rupert Murdoch, has recently expressed nervousness about investments in Russia, where News Outdoor generated the bulk of its revenue last year. Help News pick Stadium's greatest moment (New York Daily News)
The News is marking the countdown to the final game at The House That Ruth Built by reflecting on Yankee Stadium's greatest moments - and we're asking you - the reader - to help us pick out the best of the best. SEC Looks Into UAL Stock Scare; Implications For Online News? (paidContent.org via Yahoo! Finance)
A ton of digits have been devoted to this in other spots but the SEC's decision to investigate takes it to another level. The backstory: a six-year-old news story about UAL declaring bankruptcy made it into the Tribune-owned Sun-Sentinel's current news flow, was picked up by a Google News bot and, via a reporter for a newsletter, made it onto Bloomberg News. JCDecaux in talks to buy News Corp. billboard unit (AP via Yahoo! Finance)
In a deal that would create the world's largest outdoor advertising company, French conglomerate JCDecaux SA said Thursday that it is in talks to buy Russian rival News Outdoor Group from global media company News Corp. News Corp says Mark Williams interim Premiere CEO (Reuters via Yahoo! News)
News Corp. executive Mark Williams has taken over as chief executive of German pay-TV broadcaster Premiere in an interim capacity, News Corp. said after the move led to renewed takeover speculation.

Site: news - Google News
CNET News Daily Podcast: Say hello to the Palm Pre - CNET News

CNET News

CNET News Daily Podcast: Say hello to the Palm Pre
CNET News, CA - 7 hours ago
At the CES gadget extravaganza in Las Vegas, Palm has just unveiled its much-anticipated new handset, the Palm Pre, which features the new Palm Web OS. ...
Palm Unveils New 'Nova' Software, 'Palm Pre' Phone CNNMoney.com
Palm's new Pre smartphone gets lots of good buzz USA Today
Palm unveils new smart phone, operating system The Associated Press
Ars Technica - San Francisco Chronicle
all 409 news articles
Summary Of Thursday News From International Consumer Electronics Show - CNNMoney.com

ABC News

Summary Of Thursday News From International Consumer Electronics Show
CNNMoney.com - 8 hours ago
The company's Sling Media Inc. unit unveiled SlingGuide, a new Web-based way to find, watch and record your favorite television programming from anywhere. ...
Video: Loaded: Happy New Year! CBS
Consumer Electronics Show: Some New Things NBC Los Angeles
New TV trends unveiled at gadget show abc7.com
IT PRO - CBS News
all 1,094 news articles
Ballmer touts Windows 7 beta, new deals - CNET News

guardian.co.uk

Ballmer touts Windows 7 beta, new deals
CNET News, CA - 18 hours ago
Microsoft will also announce new deals for Windows Live that will see Microsoft's search engine become the default on PCs from Dell as well as touting a ...
Microsoft's news at CES not so new Seattle Times
CES News: Ballmer Keynote Doesn?t Quite Fit The Bill Twice
Windows Live Essentials released, more Windows Live news from CES LiveSide
CRN - UK - MarketWatch
all 1,159 news articles
Warsh?s Skills Push Him Toward New York Fed Position - Bloomberg

Warsh?s Skills Push Him Toward New York Fed Position
Bloomberg - 8 hours ago
8 (Bloomberg) -- The Federal Reserve is nearing a decision on the next president of the New York Fed, with Kevin Warsh?s Wall Street background and role in ...
MORTGAGES: Tenth Straight Decline Sends 30-Year Mortgage To New Low - CNNMoney.com

Xinhua

MORTGAGES: Tenth Straight Decline Sends 30-Year Mortgage To New Low
CNNMoney.com - 11 hours ago
... of mortgage-backed securities issued by Freddie Mac , Fannie Mae and Ginnie Mae," said Frank Nothaft, Freddie Mac chief economist, in a news release. ...
Business News In Brief San Jose Mercury News
all 800 news articles
New UN Gaza resolution proposed - Aljazeera.net

WELT ONLINE

New UN Gaza resolution proposed
Aljazeera.net, Qatar - 11 hours ago
Condoleezza Rice, the US secretary of state, David Miliband, the British foreign minister, and Bernard Kouchner, the French foreign minister put the new ...
News roundup: Lebanese rocket northern Israel; passengers ... USA Today
Analysis: No new Lebanon confronation over Gaza, yet Times Online
Arabs put Hamas and illegal arms in new UN draft Boston Herald
The Associated Press - 7Online.com
all 11,959 news articles
Sony Keynote High On Celebrities, Short On New Products - Wired News

San Francisco Chronicle

Sony Keynote High On Celebrities, Short On New Products
Wired News - 4 hours ago
By Priya Ganapati January 08, 2009 | 7:34:54 PMCategories: CES 2009, Home Entertainment LAS VEGAS -- It was probably the lack of any exciting new products ...
Sony's new alarm clock brings music videos, photos NetworkWorld.com
Stringer stresses convergence to save CE industry CNET News
CES: Sony Wants Wireless In Most Of Its Products CRN
all 103 news articles
BCS Title Game: The News Media Predicts - New York Times

New York Daily News

BCS Title Game: The News Media Predicts
New York Times, United States - 19 hours ago
Florida 51, Oklahoma 17: Gators dominate special teams and stymie Sam Bradford to become the new preeminent program in college football.
News and Notes from Halftime of the BCS Title Game ABC Action News
all 2,615 news articles
New Hampshire Thrift Bancshares, Inc. Announces Quarterly Dividend - CNNMoney.com

New Hampshire Thrift Bancshares, Inc. Announces Quarterly Dividend
CNNMoney.com - 9 hours ago
New Hampshire Thrift Bancshares, Inc. (NASDAQ: NHTB) has declared a regular quarterly cash dividend of thirteen cents ($0.13) per share payable January 30, ...
Obama taps Kaine as new face of Dems - Boston Globe

BBC News

Obama taps Kaine as new face of Dems
Boston Globe, United States - 7 hours ago
Obama, citing his broad-based victory in November, said Kaine -- a centrist, culturally conservative Democrat -- represents precisely the new politics that ...
Video: Va. Gov. Kaine to Take Over As DNC Chairman AssociatedPress
Live-Blogging Obama?s News Conference Wall Street Journal Blogs
all 1,365 news articles

MORE RESOURCES:
Site: Yahoo! News Search Results for babies toddler
Mother of child locked in car charged with felony (Los Angeles Daily News)

A woman accused of leaving her toddler in a locked sport utility vehicle while shopping in Van Nuys last week was charged today with a felony count of child abuse. Yoga for the whole family: (Republican-American)

Yoga is supposed to be about achieving complete relaxation. So what happens if you combine it with babies and small children ? or a bulging belly? Shopping for Baby Gear With Christiane Lemieux (New York Times)

Christiane Lemieux, co-owner, with her husband, of the home furnishings company Dwell Studio, shops for sophisticated and eco-friendly baby products. Westport designer signs with chain (Stamford Advocate)

Amy Coe of Westport wasn't happy with the selection of baby accessories, when she became a mother 16 years ago. Events Calendar (Rome Observer)

This Week Visual Arts Aug. 8 to Sept. 13 Regional Art InvitationaL at the Mohawk Valley Center for the Arts. This year's theme is "An Artist's View." Artists must be 18 years or older and live within 100 miles of Little Falls. Homicide unit investigating Elkhart toddler's injuries (22 WSBT South Bend)

ELKHART ? A little girl is hospitalized in critical condition and police are trying to find out what happened to her. The 21-month-old was brought in with severe injuries late Monday night and police said those injuries look suspicious. Get Your Vehicle Ready for the Change of Season (Beaches Leader)

(ARA) - It seems like the kids just started school, but soon you'll be packing up and hitting the road on your next family vacation. And contrary to popular belief, the weeks leading up to the trip are not the time to start getting your vehicle ready. Business And Careers (Benson News-Sun)

(ARA) - Now in its eighth season, the Emmy award-winning investigative drama CSI draws a weekly audience of about 20 million viewers. But CSI is more than simply entertainment. Fashion sniffs perfume of Asia's nouveau riche (San Francisco Chronicle)

There's an urgency in the air around the tents in Bryant Park, the center of the annual fix of fabulousness known as Fashion Week. It's a case of glam being trumped by grim: The question on everyone's minds, as raised by USA Today: Given the weakening... No charges in death of baby left in hot car (The Oxford Press)

CINCINNATI ? A woman who left her 11-month-old baby in a hot van for nearly eight hours will not face criminal charges, according to WKRC-TV Local 12. Site: babies toddler - Google News
Library Corner - Contra Costa Times

Library Corner
Contra Costa Times, CA - 20 hours ago
Mother Goose Time, 10:15 am Jan. 26, for toddlers and babies. Toddler and Preschool Time, 11:15 am Jan. 26. Family Storytime and Crafts, 7 pm Jan. ...
Ben And Jen And Babies Make 4! - TheCelebrityCafe.com

Ben And Jen And Babies Make 4!
TheCelebrityCafe.com, NY - Jan 7, 2009
The attractive Hollywood couple have one older daughter together, toddler Violet, age 3. Garner most recently was in "Juno," as a mother-to-be. ...
Babies and Mobiles part 4: quick-learners! - IntoMobile

Babies and Mobiles part 4: quick-learners!
IntoMobile, CA - 8 hours ago
So I?ve had a bit of a break since the last post I wrote about the relationship that Mobiles have with my Baby (soon to be Toddler) ? you can check out the ...
MD tells woman: That's no kidney stone, it's a baby - CTV.ca

MD tells woman: That's no kidney stone, it's a baby
CTV.ca, Canada - 16 hours ago
But the toddler now appears as rambunctious as any his age, running around inside the house and playing with his toys. Nicholas is faring well also, ...
The Lie We Love - RH Reality Check

The Lie We Love
RH Reality Check, DC - 23 hours ago
DNA testing showed the toddler to be Escobar's child. In a similar case from 2006, Raquel Par, another Guatemalan woman, reported being drugged while ...
My Superpowers Came In Handy Again. - Seattle Post Intelligencer

My Superpowers Came In Handy Again.
Seattle Post Intelligencer - Jan 4, 2009
I will help open doors for people with strollers/babies/toddlers. I will help babysit now and then. I will even change diaper blow-outs and have many times. ...
Lots of angles in making your house safe for tots - Boston Herald

Lots of angles in making your house safe for tots
Boston Herald, United States - Jan 6, 2009
By Yvonne Finnerty / Ask Nanny Yvonne How do I make my house safe for my newborn and what are the dangers as he becomes a toddler? Thanks. ...
10 Common Misconceptions About Breastfeeding Your Baby - Green Prophet

10 Common Misconceptions About Breastfeeding Your Baby
Green Prophet, Israel - 21 hours ago
Until starting gan the toddler nursed freely throughout the day. When the mother arrived to pick up her daughter on the first day, she found the staff quite ...
Joovy Ergo Caboose Stroller: All Aboard for This Tandem Stroller! - Celebrity Baby Blog

Joovy Ergo Caboose Stroller: All Aboard for This Tandem Stroller!
Celebrity Baby Blog, NY - Jan 7, 2009
By the time the baby is old enough to sit in the front seat, the toddler would move to the rear bench seat or have the option to stand on the ...
Mother Goose on the Loose for babies at library - The Daily News of Newburyport

Mother Goose on the Loose for babies at library
The Daily News of Newburyport, MA - Jan 7, 2009
While toddler story hours are offered weekly, Babytimes for newborns to 23 months were only offered biweekly. Babytimes usually draws a crowd of 15 to 25 ...
Home | Site Map | Resource Links